Scatter graphs and predictions
8 questions · grades 2 to 6 · Answers on the last page
- Question 1
Each part describes two variables.
(a) The age of a car and its value. What type of correlation would you expect?
(b) The shoe sizes of 30 adults and their scores in the same spelling test. What type of correlation would you expect?
- Question 2
The scatter graph shows the hours of revision and the test scores of 12 students.
(a) Write down the type of correlation.
(b) Kai says, "This proves that revising more causes higher scores." Explain why Kai is wrong.
- Question 3
The scatter graph shows revision hours and test scores. A line of best fit has been drawn. Its equation is .
(a) Use the line of best fit to estimate the score of a student who revised for 6.5 hours.
(b) Explain why it would not be sensible to use the line to estimate the score of a student who revised for 25 hours.
- Question 4
The scatter graph shows the study time and practice score of 12 students. A line of best fit has been drawn.
(a) Use the line of best fit to estimate the score for 7 hours of study.
(b) Explain why using the line to estimate the score for 25 hours of study is less reliable.
- Question 5
The scatter graph shows the study time and practice score of 12 students. A line of best fit has been drawn.
(a) Work out the gradient of the line of best fit.
(b) Does the scatter graph prove that extra study caused higher scores? Explain your answer.
- Question 6
The scatter graph shows the hours of sunshine and the number of umbrellas sold by a shop on 20 days.
(a) Describe the relationship shown by the scatter graph.
(b) A newspaper says sunshine stops people buying umbrellas. Does the scatter graph prove this? Explain your answer.
(c) The point for the day with 11 hours of sunshine does not fit the pattern. What is this point called, and how should it be treated when drawing a line of best fit?
- Question 7
For a sample of cars, the line of best fit for , the stopping distance in metres, against , the speed in m/s, is for speeds from 10 m/s to 30 m/s.
(a) Interpret the gradient 3.2 in this context.
(b) Lily says stopping distance is directly proportional to speed. Is she correct? Give a reason.
(c) Estimate the stopping distance at 20 m/s.
- Question 8
The scatter graph shows the length and mass of 12 objects of one type. A line of best fit has been drawn.
(a) Use the line of best fit to estimate the mass of an object of length 24 cm.
Worked solutions and marks
Question 1
(a) Negative
- As age increases, value tends to decrease.
- B1 Correct answer: Negative.
(b) No correlation
- For adults, shoe size and spelling have no link, so expect no correlation.
- B1 Correct answer: No correlation.
Question 2
(a) Positive
- As hours of revision increase, scores tend to increase.
- B1 Correct answer: Positive.
(b) Correlation shows an association, not that one causes the other.
- A scatter graph shows the variables are linked, but other factors (such as interest in the subject) could affect both.
- C1 Correlation does not show causation (another factor may be responsible).
Question 3
(a) 48
- Read up from 6.5 to the line and across: .
- B1 Answer in the range 46 to 50.
(b) 25 hours is far outside the data (extrapolation), and the trend may not continue; the line would even give more than the maximum mark.
- The data only go up to about 9 hours. Beyond that the pattern may change: the line gives , which is likely impossible.
- C1 Outside the range of the data (extrapolation), so the trend may not continue.
Question 4
(a)
- Draw a line up from 7 hours on the Study time axis to the line of best fit.
- Read across to the Score axis: about 33.
- B1 An answer from 32 to 34, read from the line of best fit.
(b) 25 hours lies outside the observed range, so this is extrapolation; the relationship may change beyond the recorded data.
- Therefore 25 hours lies outside the observed range, so this is extrapolation; the relationship may change beyond the recorded data.
- C1 Correct conclusion with supporting reasoning: 25 hours lies outside the observed range, so this is extrapolation; the relationship may change beyond the recorded data.
Question 5
(a)
- Divide change in score by change in study time.
- Therefore .
- M1 Divide change in score by change in study time.
- A1 Correct answer:
(b) No. An observed association does not prove causation; other factors could affect both study time and scores.
- No. An observed association does not prove causation; other factors could affect both study time and scores.
- C1 Correct conclusion with supporting reasoning: No. An observed association does not prove causation; other factors could affect both study time and scores.
Question 6
(a) On sunnier days the shop tends to sell fewer umbrellas.
- On sunnier days the shop tends to sell fewer umbrellas.
- C1 Correct conclusion with supporting reasoning: On sunnier days the shop tends to sell fewer umbrellas.
(b) No. Correlation does not show cause; rain on days with little sunshine is a more likely reason for umbrella sales.
- No. Correlation does not show cause; rain on days with little sunshine is a more likely reason for umbrella sales.
- C1 Correct conclusion with supporting reasoning: No. Correlation does not show cause; rain on days with little sunshine is a more likely reason for umbrella sales.
(c) It is an outlier. Check it is not a recording error, and do not let it pull the line of best fit away from the pattern of the other points.
- It is an outlier. Check it is not a recording error, and do not let it pull the line of best fit away from the pattern of the other points.
- C1 Correct conclusion with supporting reasoning: It is an outlier. Check it is not a recording error, and do not let it pull the line of best fit away from the pattern of the other points.
Question 7
(a) For each extra 1 m/s of speed, the stopping distance increases by about 3.2 m.
- The gradient is the change in for each increase of 1 in .
- C1 Stopping distance goes up about 3.2 m for each 1 m/s of speed.
(b) No: the line does not pass through the origin (intercept ).
- Direct proportion means : a straight line through .
- This line has intercept , so doubling the speed does not double the distance.
- C1 "No", because the line does not pass through the origin (for example 10 m/s gives 17 m but 20 m/s gives 49 m, not 34 m).
(c) 49 m
- .
- B1 Correct answer: 49 m.
Question 8
(a)
- Draw a line up from 24 cm on the Length axis to the line of best fit.
- Read across to the Mass axis: about 56 g.
- B1 An answer from 54 g to 58 g, read from the line of best fit.