The extract · lines 5 to 6
The borrowed voice
Original contemporary fiction; Salma attends a choir rehearsal in a hall where her mother once sang.
- 1The hall was being used for storage, so the choir stood between a folded climbing frame and stacks of plastic chairs.
- 2Salma placed her music on a chair that had lost one rubber foot. It rocked whenever she turned a page.
- 3Across the room, people greeted one another in the easy shorthand of people who had met here for years.
- 4She recognised some of their faces from photographs. In each photograph her mother had stood somewhere near the middle.
- 5The conductor gave her a folder with her mother’s name rubbed almost smooth. Salma held it by its edges.
- 6Inside, pencilled arrows crowded the staves. One word, breathe, appeared so often that it began to feel like an instruction for living.
- 7They started badly. Notes collided beneath the low ceiling, bright fragments that would not fit together however firmly the conductor gestured.
- 8Salma mouthed the first verse. The woman beside her sang with a rough, confident warmth, leaving room for nobody to hide.
- 9At the difficult turn, the conductor stopped them. A radiator answered with three dry knocks, and somebody apologised to it.
- 10The room laughed. Salma laughed a little later, once she realised that this was allowed even here, even now.
- 11They tried again. She let out one note, quietly, as if returning something borrowed without attracting the owner’s attention.
- 12The woman beside her leaned closer, not to listen but to show her the line. A flour mark whitened her sleeve.
- 13Salma’s mother had always insisted that the choir was ordinary. As a child, Salma had understood that as a complaint.
- 14Now she watched the conductor balance his score on a paint tin and saw the folder repaired with kitchen tape.
- 15At the last verse the woman lost her place. For two bars Salma sang alone, hearing her own voice without its usual shelter.
- 16Nobody turned. The other singers entered at the next line, and the song carried on with its small mistake inside it.
- 17When they finished, the conductor asked whether she would come next week. He was already sorting the untidy pile of music.
- 18She said yes before examining whether she could bear to. He nodded, as though this were an entirely manageable arrangement.
- 19Salma rubbed a flour mark from the folder. Then she stopped, leaving a pale thumbprint beside her mother’s name.
- 20On the way out she moved the chair with the missing foot against the wall, where it would not trouble anyone.
Original fiction written for this course.
Skill drill: a Paper 1 Q1 part asks about lines 5 to 6 of The borrowed voice. Which of these details could its answer use?